One Eyed Jack's - Breaded Pork Tenderloin Restaurant

Winamac, Indiana

Restaurant Information

Address:: 124 N Market St, Winamac, IN 46996
Phone:: (574) 946-4343
Website:: https://oneeyedjackswinamac.com
Price Range:: $
Amenities:: Wheelchair Accessible, Outdoor Seating, Full Bar, Accepts Credit Cards, Free Parking / On-Site Parking, Kid-Friendly / High Chairs Available, Happy Hour Specials

Rating Summary

5.00 out of 5 stars based on 3 customer reviews.

Visitors to One Eyed Jack's have rated their breaded pork tenderloin experience and shared their feedback below.

About One Eyed Jack's

One Eyed Jack's in Winamac, IN. Rated 5.0/5. Famous for thick, crispy breaded pork tenderloin and classic Midwest hospitality.

One Eyed Jack's is located in Winamac, Indiana and serves breaded pork tenderloin sandwiches, a beloved Midwest tradition. Whether you're a local or passing through, this restaurant offers an authentic BPT experience.

Customer Reviews

Randy G. - 5 out of 5 stars January 3, 2026

This Breaded Pork Tenderloin is easily one of the largest I’ve ever seen at approximately 7” x 12” and about ¾” to 1½” thick. The portion size alone is impressive. The breading was slightly oily for my preference but it was mostly crunchy which I appreciated. More importantly the flavor was excellent and very satisfying. The tater tots were also complemented the meal nicely. I chose water so I could fully appreciate the flavors without distraction. The sandwich was so large that I had to cut it down. I still ended up with enough leftovers for two additional sandwiches. In the end it was absolutely worth both the drive and the wait. I would not hesitate to return and would recommend it to anyone looking for an oversized and flavorful Breaded Pork Tenderloin.

David S. - 5 out of 5 stars September 2, 2025

I didn’t take on the BPT Challenge, but I did order the original “Jack Jumble” tenderloin for $12.49 one of eight different tenderloin options on the menu. After driving all day from Spring Green, WI, where I’d visited Frank Lloyd Wright’s Taliesin, I was more than ready for a good meal and I ended up eating the whole thing. The tenderloin was battered rather than breaded, and it hit the spot... crispy on the outside, tender inside, and full of flavor. Definitely worth the detour on our way to Cleveland. After dinner, we stayed overnight at the 10-56 Brewery north of Winamac in Knox, IN, a Harvest Host location, which made for a perfect end to a long travel day.

Odessa S. - 5 out of 5 stars May 17, 2025

I made the hour-plus drive to Winamac, Indiana yesterday just to finally try the famous tenderloin at One Eyed Jack’s I’ve been hearing so much about. And honestly… it did not disappoint! It was massive, moist, and full of flavor... definitely lived up to the buzz. That said, Jonesy’s Junction in Akron, Indiana still holds the top spot for me. I know a lot of folks love those huge tenderloins, but personally, I like mine about half the size (and half the price 😅). One Eyed Jack’s definitely earned a place in my Top 5. Solid food, great experience, and totally worth the trip.

One Eyed Jack's - Breaded Pork Tenderloin in Winamac, Indiana

About This Tenderloin at One Eyed Jack's